Why The Green And Brown M&M's Are So Controversial (2024)

Summary

  • The Green and Brown M&M's mascots caused controversy due to a minor change in their appearance, with conservatives criticizing the shift as being too "woke" and feminists arguing it was a poor attempt at inclusivity.
  • A petition was created calling for the original designs to be brought back, which gained over 20 thousand signatures and was used by conservative pundits as fodder for their anti-woke argument.
  • M&M's eventually retired the mascots and replaced them with Maya Rudolph but faced universal derision, leading to the spokescandies returning in a high-profile Super Bowl commercial in 202
  • Mars' handling of the situation was viewed negatively.

Though they are seemingly innocuous candy mascots, the Green and Brown M&M's characters were the source of major controversy and backlash. While the M&M's parent company Mars has been using mascot characters to sell the product since the 1950s, the so-called spokescandies as they are known today didn't come into being until the middle of the 1990s. Immediately beloved, the CGI anthropomorphic confections each have their own personality and are modeled after the various colors that the sweet treat comes in. The roster grew to include nearly every color by the turn of the new millennium, and they certainly helped Mars to pump up their sales.

Perhaps one of the most successful food mascot campaigns of all time, the spokescandies have sported an impressive roster of voice talents behind the scenes including John Goodman, Jon Lovitz, and J.K. Simmons. The Red M&M's mascot has been voiced by Billy West for nearly 30 years, and he has been the glue that has held the entire ad campaign together across the decades. Even though the playful spokescandies have changed in minor ways since the '90s, a seemingly unimportant tweak to the Green and Brown M&M's mascot caused a massive backlash.

Why The Green And Brown M&M's Are So Controversial (2)

For a time, the Green and Brown M&M's mascots were the only female-presenting characters in the lineup and their initial character designs included knee-high heeled boots for Green and tall high heels for Brown. However, in an effort to make the characters more inclusive, Green's boots were swapped out for sensible flats, and Brown was given a more manageable heel. This choice enraged conservative pundit Tucker Carlson who lamented that the green M&M was no longer "sexy" (via Salon). While it could have simply been blown out of proportion by the 24-hour Fox News content cycle, it had an effect in the real world.

Some feminists critiqued the change as a poor attempt at being inclusive (via The Independent), but most of the backlash stemmed from the conservative side who critiqued the change for being too woke. Whether it was made in earnest or in jest, a major petition was created on Change.org which called for Mars to bring Green's original design back, and it garnered over 20 thousand signatures. Though there was an edge of silliness to the aforementioned petition, it was picked up by conservative pundits and used as fodder for their anti-woke argument. Mars responded with an all-female spokescandies lineup which was resoundingly rejected.

M&M's Replaced The Spokescandies With Maya Rudolph

Why The Green And Brown M&M's Are So Controversial (3)

Following the controversy in 2022, M&M's retired the mascots and replaced them with Maya Rudolph. The SNL alum was tapped to be the company's lone spokesperson and the strange ads were meant to take the heat off of the spokescandies following the conservative backlash. However, Mars' choice was met with universal derision, and the M&M's were eventually returned in a high-profile Super Bowl commercial that told a bit of a story arc involving Maya Rudolph trying to kill them off. In the end, the spokescandies returned to the spotlight in 2023, and they seemingly survived the conservative backlash, even if Mars looks bad in the process.

Your changes have been saved

Email Is sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Manage Your List

Follow

Followed

Follow with Notifications

Follow

Unfollow

Why The Green And Brown M&M's Are So Controversial (2024)

FAQs

Why The Green And Brown M&M's Are So Controversial? ›

The Green and Brown M&M's mascots caused controversy due to a minor change in their appearance, with conservatives criticizing the shift as being too "woke" and feminists arguing it was a poor attempt at inclusivity.

What is the M&M controversy twice? ›

The controversy continued this year, when M&M's decided to create some personalities for their characters, return the boots to the green candy, and feature a bag with only female spokescandies on it for International Women's Day, one of them being a new purple peanut M&M.

What did M&Ms get in trouble for? ›

A controversy erupted when M&M's made changes to its roster of characters and to the shoes they wear.

Why did they remove green M&M heels? ›

On Thursday, Mars said the company would be redesigning the M&M'S characters as part of the brand's commitment “to creating a world where everyone feels they belong.” For example, the green M&M traded her go-go boots for a pair of sneakers, and the brown M&M changed her motto to “Not bossy.

Why are they getting rid of the M&M's? ›

On Jan. 24, Mars, Incorporated — the company that owns the M&M's brand — told the world that their iconic mascots would be replaced by comedian Maya Rudolph. The company said it was due to criticism of the brand getting “too political,” thanks to their controversial makeovers of the mascots last year.

What is the issue with the green M&M? ›

Summary. The Green and Brown M&M's mascots caused controversy due to a minor change in their appearance, with conservatives criticizing the shift as being too "woke" and feminists arguing it was a poor attempt at inclusivity.

What M&M color was canceled? ›

In 1976, Mars eliminated red-colored M&M's because of health concerns over the dye amaranth (FD&C Red #2), which was a suspected carcinogen, and replaced them with orange M&M's. This was done despite the fact that M&M's did not contain the dye; the action was purely to satisfy worried consumers.

Why doesn't the green M&M wear boots anymore? ›

Now she's wearing sensible sneakers. Why the change?” Mars Inc, the company that owns the world-renowned M&M candies announced on Thursday that it was changing the look of its famous characters as part of its “global commitment to creating a world where everyone feels they belong and society is inclusive.

Why is M&M changing their name? ›

The company recently announced it was dropping its 'spokescandies' because the desexualisation of the green M&M had upset people so much. M&M's told the world it had replaced the candies with comic Maya Rudolph. And now it has gone a step further, by changing its name completely. Goodbye M&M's, hello Ma&Ya's.

Why were M&Ms banned? ›

The FDA concluded that the food colorant could not be presumed to be safe for human consumption and banned it in 1976. Red M&M's disappeared shortly after the FDA issued its ruling , suggesting they were one of the Red No. 2 culprits.

What does the MS in M&M stand for? ›

The two 'M's represent the names of Forrest E. Mars Sr., the founder of Newark Company, and Bruce Murrie, son of Hershey Chocolate's president William F. R. Murrie, who had a 20 percent share in the product.

Why not to eat M&M's? ›

Another concern, probably the most crucial, is its high sugar content. The intake of more sugars can cause higher blood pressure, inflammation, weight gain, diabetes, and fatty liver disease. So, it's best to restrain from having M&M's frequently or in high numbers.

What is the controversy with the female M&M character? ›

Misogyny and sexism are still very prominent, even in something as insignificant as M&M's characters. The appeal of the green and brown M&M's was to be sexy and not have a personality like the guys. When MARS decided to redesign them, it caused controversy.

Why was the Purple M&M controversial? ›

Conservatives immediately suggested that the new purple candy must be transgender, and the candies were labeled “woke.” The last straw seemed to come in December when the candy introduced all-female packaging to promote International Women's Day.

Why is M&M rebranding? ›

A Bold Decision

M&Ms recently chose to rebrand its iconic M&M characters to better reflect consumers. In an effort to de-sexualize her, the company swapped the Green M&M's feminine boots with sneakers.

Why did they take the boots off the green M&M? ›

About a year ago, Mars Wrigley rebranded some of its M&M characters to be more inclusive, including a redesign of the green M&M that replaced her high-heeled boots with sneakers.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 5362

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.